Three Revenue Recognition Mistakes I See More Than I Should

Here’s a question worth asking before your next close: are you recognizing revenue when you’ve actually earned it?

Not when the invoice goes out. Not when the money hits the account. When you’ve actually delivered what you promised.

For a lot of businesses, those three things happen at roughly the same time and it doesn’t matter much. But for businesses that take upfront payments, sell online, or have any complexity in what they deliver — the gap between “cash received” and “revenue earned” is real. And if you’re not accounting for it correctly, your financials are telling a story that isn’t quite true.

Here’s a quick disclaimer before we get into it: ASC 606 (the accounting standard that governs revenue recognition) is a big topic and not all of it applies to every business. A solo consultant billing hourly for straightforward work probably doesn’t need to think hard about this. A business with retainers, subscriptions, bundled offerings, or online sales? Worth a closer look.

Here are the three situations I see most often.


1. Upfront Invoices Going Straight to Revenue

This is the most common one and it shows up everywhere — professional services firms, coaching businesses, software companies, and increasingly DTC brands with subscription or membership models.

The scenario: a client pays a retainer, a deposit, or a prepayment upfront. The money hits the account. It gets recorded as revenue. Everyone moves on.

The problem: you haven’t earned that revenue yet. Under ASC 606, revenue is recognized when (or as) you satisfy a performance obligation — meaning when you’ve actually delivered the service or product the client paid for. If a client pays you $12,000 in January for a year of advisory work, you’ve earned $1,000 in January. Not $12,000.

Recording the full amount as revenue in January overstates your income for that period and understates it for the months when you actually do the work. If you’re on cash basis for tax purposes this might not affect your tax return, but it absolutely affects the accuracy of your financial statements — and if you’re trying to understand your real profitability, manage cash flow, or present financials to a lender, the distortion matters.

The fix: upfront payments should hit deferred revenue (a liability on your balance sheet) first, then get recognized as revenue as you deliver the service. It’s a straightforward journal entry and it makes your financials actually reflect reality.


2. Online Sales Recorded as Revenue at the Point of Sale

This one is particularly relevant for ecommerce and DTC businesses — including anyone selling through Shopify, WooCommerce, or similar platforms.

The scenario: a customer places an order. Shopify records the sale. The revenue hits your books. Done.

The problem: if there’s any delay between the order and delivery — and there almost always is — you’ve recognized revenue before you’ve satisfied your performance obligation. The customer hasn’t received what they paid for yet. Until they do, that payment is technically a liability (you owe them a product), not income.

This matters most when:

  • You have meaningful fulfillment delays (custom orders, backordered inventory, pre-orders)
  • You’re doing significant volume and the gap between order and delivery is consistent
  • You’re approaching a period end (month end, year end) with open orders

For businesses with fast, predictable fulfillment, the practical impact is often small. But for businesses with pre-order models, made-to-order products, or any kind of inventory constraint that creates consistent delays — the revenue sitting in “sold but not shipped” can be a meaningful number that shouldn’t be on your income statement yet.

The fix: map your revenue recognition to fulfillment, not order date. Most ecommerce platforms have reporting that can help you identify open orders at period end. Your accounting system should reflect delivery, not just sale.


3. The Swap Option Problem (This One Might Not Be for You)

This one is more specific, so if it doesn’t sound like your business, skip ahead. But I’ve seen it happen more than once and it’s worth flagging.

The scenario: a customer purchases a bundle of something (electronic files, digital credits, units of a product) and later asks to swap some of the unused portion for something else — a different format, a physical version, a different product entirely. The original sale was recorded as fully earned revenue at the point of purchase.

The problem: if there’s any standing expectation (even an informal one, even one that’s not in the contract) that customers can swap unused portions for something of equivalent value, that swap option is a separate performance obligation. And a performance obligation that hasn’t been satisfied yet means some portion of that original revenue isn’t fully earned.

The tricky part here is that the swap option often isn’t written down anywhere. It’s a verbal accommodation, a customer service practice, an informal thing the team just does. Which means it can be happening without anyone in accounting knowing it’s happening — and without anyone thinking about what it means for how the original sale should be recorded.

If your business has any kind of credit, unit, or bundle model where customers have an expectation of flexibility in how they redeem what they’ve purchased, it’s worth having a conversation about whether that flexibility constitutes a performance obligation and how it should be reflected in your revenue recognition.


Why This Actually Matters

Revenue recognition mistakes don’t always feel urgent because they often balance out over time. The retainer you over-recognized in January gets under-recognized in the following months. The Shopify orders that shipped a week late eventually deliver. It evens out.

Except it doesn’t — not perfectly, and not in the ways that matter.

If your financials are used to make decisions (pricing, hiring, investment, borrowing), the period-level distortions affect those decisions. If you’re presenting to a lender or investor, misstated revenue raises questions. And if you ever go through an audit or due diligence process, revenue recognition is one of the first places people look.

Getting it right isn’t about compliance for its own sake. It’s about having financials that actually tell you what’s happening in your business.


Chris Geno is a CPA and fractional controller at High Rock Accounting, working with professional services firms, ecommerce businesses, and high-growth DTC brands on financial strategy and reporting. Not sure if your revenue recognition is set up correctly? Worth a quick conversation.

Enjoyed this article? Consider Sharing

want to see how high rock can streamline your accounting?

Explor more insights

stay ahead with high rock insights

Subscribe to our High Rock Insights newsletter below.
© Copyright 2025 High Rock Accounting