Here’s how most commission conversations start: someone on the team brings in new business, and the owner decides they should get a piece of it. Reasonable. Fair. Motivating. So they set a percentage, shake hands, and move on.
Six months later, something feels off. Maybe cash is tighter than expected. Maybe the team is behaving in ways nobody anticipated. Maybe a commission payment went out on a deal that hasn’t fully closed yet and now there’s an awkward conversation to have. Commission plans feel simple because the concept is simple. The execution, though, is where firms get into trouble.
Here’s what’s worth thinking through before you build one, and what to watch for if you already have one in place.
When Commissions Actually Make Sense
Let’s start with the good news: commissions can work really well in professional services. And not just for dedicated sales roles.
The cleanest win is when a team member who’s already executing work identifies an opportunity for new or adjacent work and brings it in. They’re in the relationship. They understand the client’s needs. They surface something valuable that might not have come through any other channel. That’s genuinely worth rewarding. It costs you less than an external referral, it deepens the relationship, and it creates a natural incentive for your whole team to think like business developers, not just executors.
A dedicated sales role with a commission structure also makes sense when you’ve grown to the point where business development is a full-time job. The key is being clear about what you’re paying for and what behavior you’re trying to drive. Which leads us to where things get complicated.
The Cash Timing Problem
This one doesn’t get enough attention. Most commission plans pay at the win. Deal closes, commission pays. Simple, clean, motivating. Except: have you actually been paid yet?
In professional services, payment timelines vary. A client might sign in October and pay their first invoice in December. Or in January. Or, if they’re slow, February. If your commission pays at contract signature and your client pays net 60, you’ve just created a cash flow exposure. You’re paying out before cash has come in.
This gets worse when commissions are meaningful percentages of large deals. A 5% commission on a $200,000 engagement is $10,000 going out the door before you’ve collected a dollar. The fix is straightforward: tie commission payments to cash collection, not contract signature. Pay when the client pays, at least for the initial payment. It’s a slightly less exciting story to tell the sales team, but it’s a much healthier one for your cash position. And honestly, a good salesperson will understand why it matters.
The Margin Impact Problem
Commission plans are often designed without modeling what they actually cost. A 10% commission sounds reasonable until you run it against your gross margin. If your gross margin on a typical engagement is 40%, a 10% commission on revenue is actually 25% of your gross profit. Add overhead and you’re looking at a meaningful impact on what actually drops to the bottom line.
This gets more acute when commissions scale. Tiered structures (higher percentage after hitting a threshold) are designed to drive bigger wins, but they can quietly erode margins on your largest deals, which are often the ones you most need to be profitable.
Before you finalize any commission structure, model it. Take a few real or hypothetical engagements and run the math. What does the commission cost as a percentage of gross profit, not just revenue? What happens at the high end of the scale? Does the plan still work for the business at full utilization? The goal is a plan that rewards performance without surprising you financially when it works exactly as designed.
The Quota Gaming Problem
If your commission plan includes quotas, thresholds, or accelerators, expect your team to optimize for them.
That’s not a criticism. It’s just how incentives work. If hitting $500,000 in bookings by December 31 unlocks a bonus, expect deals to get pulled forward. If a quarterly threshold resets in January, expect some wins to get pushed into the new quarter. If hitting a cumulative threshold unlocks a higher rate on all prior commissions, expect a surge of activity right before the trigger. None of this is dishonest. But it can create lumpy revenue, rushed closes, and clients who feel pressured rather than served.
The antidote is designing your plan with these dynamics in mind. Smooth out thresholds where you can. Consider annual structures rather than quarterly ones if your sales cycle allows. And watch the data over time: if you’re seeing unusual patterns in when deals close, your commission plan is probably the reason.
A Note on the Handoff
When the person who sells isn’t the person who delivers, commission plans can create subtle problems. The salesperson is incentivized to close. The delivery team is incentivized to execute well. If those two things are misaligned (a deal that was oversold, a scope that was underdefined, a client whose expectations don’t match what was actually contracted), the friction lands on the delivery team while the commission has already been paid.
This doesn’t mean you shouldn’t pay commissions to salespeople. It means the deal structure matters. Tight scoping, realistic expectations, and a handoff process that actually transfers context (not just a signed contract) are what protect the delivery team and the client relationship. And if the salesperson is the familiar face and the executor isn’t? Make sure the relationship doesn’t evaporate post-close. That’s a retention problem as much as a delivery problem.
What a Good Commission Plan Actually Does
A well-designed commission plan drives the behavior you want. It rewards the wins that matter, at the timing that works for your cash flow, at a rate that makes sense for your margins, with structure that doesn’t create perverse incentives.
That’s a lot of variables to get right. Most firms don’t get all of them right on the first try, and that’s okay. The important thing is to revisit the plan regularly, model the actual cost before finalizing it, and watch for behaviors that tell you something is off. Commissions are a powerful tool. Like any powerful tool, they work best when you understand exactly what you’re building with them.
Chris Geno is a CPA and fractional controller at High Rock Accounting, working with professional services firms on financial strategy, compensation planning, and operations. Building or revisiting a commission structure? It’s worth running the numbers first.